Skip to content
Take $5 off $50 with code FEBFIVE (Cannot be combined with other discount codes)
Take $5 off $50 with code FEBFIVE (Cannot be combined with other discount codes)
wil live replay

Instagram Live Replay: PYO Cookies with Wilmalyn!

What in the world is a PYO cookie?!

Have you ever heard of PYO cookies? They're a recent trend in the world of baking, and they're quickly gaining popularity on social media platforms like Instagram. PYO stands for "paint your own," which means that these cookies come with a blank canvas and a set of edible paints, allowing you to unleash your inner artist and create a delicious masterpiece. But how do you make, package, and paint a PYO cookie? Luckily, Wilmalyn has got you covered. In a recent Instagram Live video, she shared her expert tips and tricks for creating the perfect PYO cookie. In this blog post, we'll give you a recap of Wilmalyn's live video, so you can learn how to make your own PYO cookies at home. Get ready to channel your inner Picasso and let's get started!

Our Cookie Countess Stenciling Icing Mix in Tuxedo Black has received rave reviews for its excellent performance in creating crisp, clean designs on cookies and cakes. Cookiers love how easy it is to use and the professional-looking results it delivers.


"I used this for my first set of PYO cookies and I'm hooked! Makes stenciling with black a breeze. Will definitely be back for more!" 

- Michelle

Need an extra set of hands while stenciling? The Stencil Genie® has come to the rescue! This stencil holder frame is the perfect fit for our stencils. You simply place your stencil between the 2 frames with embedded magnets, and place over your cookie. The frame has 2 sides of different thicknesses so you are sure to find the perfect fit.


"This is such a neat idea! Trying to stencil without this can be tricky and blotchy!
Love this tool and how it creates the look you want!" - Sara

The Cookie Countess Stencil Scraper is an essential tool for any baking enthusiast looking to create beautiful and professional-looking designs on cookies and cakes. This scraper is specially designed to help you smooth out icing and remove excess frosting for clean and crisp designs. With its comfortable grip and durable design, The Cookie Countess Stencil Scraper is the perfect addition to your baking toolkit. 


"I love these stencil scrapers! They are heavy duty and not flimsy, they work great, and they are a must have for my work flow." - Britney

Our premium quality counter cover is made from food-grade silicone that is heat-resistant, non-stick, and easy to clean. The generously sized mat is perfect for rolling out dough, cutting cookies, and assembling cakes, providing a clean, non-slip surface that helps keep your countertops clean and scratch-free. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced baker, The Cookie Countess Counter Cover is an essential tool that will elevate your baking game to the next level!


"I love this mat so much I bought a second one. I could use a third one. They protect my counter and I love rolling my dough out on this mat." - Kristen G

Easter & Spring PYO Stencils

Previous article Live tutorial replay! Airbrushing 101 with Hillary
Next article Instagram Live Replay: Florals with Sarah!


Liba - July 17, 2023

Thank you for the video. I enjoyed and learned a lot!
Can I use very thick royal icing that I make myself instead of using the special stenciling icing?
The Cookie Countess replied:
Absolutely, you can! Have fun! 😊

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields

  • cookie glossary cover

    Cookier Glossary

    Welcome to the sweet and intricate world of cookie decorating! Whether you're a seasoned baker or a newcomer eager to delve into the art of decorated sugar cookies, understanding the unique language of "cookiers" is essential. This glossary is your...

    Read now
  • free downloads blog header

    Free Downloads & Resources

    Here is where you can find all of the digital download freebies and links we've shared on social media. If you can't find what you're looking for, please email us at and we can point you in the right...

    Read now