Skip to content
⭐️⭐️⭐️ Add $40 to your cart, take $5 off with code SAVE5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️
⭐️⭐️⭐️ Add $40 to your cart, take $5 off with code SAVE5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️
Countess Rewards My Wishlist ❤ Recipes Shipping & Returns
Valentine's Day Shop

Valentine's Day Shop

  • Fairy Bear PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Your wish is granted! The Fairy Princess Teddy Bear is here with her wings and flower crown. Design Size is 2.5 x 2.65 inches Overall stencil size ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Ice Cream Cat Unicorn PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    What do you call a unicorn kitty? A caticorn! This sweet cat has many fun areas to paint. Design Size is 2.7 x 2.7 inches Overall stencil size is 5...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Spring Greenery 2 Piece Stencil Set

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 10.00 - $ 10.00
    $ 10.00
    $ 10.00 - $ 10.00
    $ 10.00
    in stock

    Use these flower elements on their own, or layer them for a unique look. Includes leaves and flowers, 2 designs on each stencil. For easiest applic...

    View full details
    $ 10.00 - $ 10.00
    $ 10.00
    $ 10.00 - $ 10.00
    $ 10.00

  • Love Pattern with Hearts Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    The word LOVE repeated with hearts. A perfect background stencil for Valentine's Day, weddings, and anniversaries. Overall size is approximately 5...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Big Cat Love PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Lions and Tigers and Hearts - oh my! Kids will love painting these cute animals. Design Size is 3 x 2.15 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5"...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Heart Quilted Pattern Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    This stencil has a dainty quilted heart perfect for Valentine's Day, weddings, and anniversaries. Overall size is approximately 5.5" x 5.5". PINK ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Heart Confetti Pattern Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Large and small scattered hearts make this stencil perfect for Valentine's Day, weddings, and anniversaries. Overall size is approximately 5.5" x ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Bear with Candy PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    A cuddly Teddy Bear with a Valentine's Day gift for you. Design Size is 2.5 x 2.5 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in imag...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
  • PYO Paint Palettes - Valentine's Day - The Cookie Countess

    PYO Paint Palettes - Valentine's Day

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    in stock

    Edible Paint Palettes in sweet Valentine's Day colors. Edible paint in 4 colors: Red, Purple, Neon Pink, Muted Pink. Palettes come 12 to a pouch. ...

    View full details
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • PYO Paint Brushes - The Cookie Countess

    Food Safe Paint Brushes for PYO Cookies - Pack of 60

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    in stock

    Disposable paint brushes to accompany your PYO cookies. These are high quality brushes with soft bristles for easier painting! Sold in packs of 5 ...

    View full details
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
  • Love Bug PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista - The Cookie Countess

    Love Bug PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Love Bug stencil. Design size is 2.75" x 3.75"  Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as it's own design! Overall stencil size is approximately 5.5" ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
  • Love Bug - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Love Bug - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Love Bug - Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    Love Bug Cookie Cutter - stencil sold separately.    This cutter is designed specifically to work with our Love Bug stencil. They're the per...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Conversation Hearts PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista - The Cookie Countess

    Conversation Hearts PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Conversation Hearts stencil. Matching cookie cutter can be found here. Desi...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
  • Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    This cutter has been designed to pair perfectly with our Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO stencil. Cutter size is 3.5" x 3" All elements o...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Conversation Hearts Classic Large 2" Sayings Stencil Set - The Cookie Countess
    Conversation Hearts Classic Large 2" Sayings Stencil Set - The Cookie Countess
    Save 20% Save %

    Conversation Hearts Classic Large 2" Sayings Stencil Set

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 16.50
    $ 16.50 - $ 16.50
    $ 16.50
    $ 13.20
    $ 13.20 - $ 13.20
    $ 13.20
    in stock

    Larger than our original Conversation Hearts stencil. We have a cookie cutter to match this stencil available here! Phrases: True Love, Be Mine, Le...

    View full details
    $ 16.50
    $ 16.50 - $ 16.50
    $ 16.50
    $ 13.20
    $ 13.20 - $ 13.20
    $ 13.20
    Save 20% Save %
  • Modern Conversation Hearts Large 2" Sayings Stencil Set - The Cookie Countess
    Save 20% Save %

    Modern Conversation Hearts Large 2" Sayings Stencil Set

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 16.50
    $ 16.50 - $ 16.50
    $ 16.50
    $ 13.20
    $ 13.20 - $ 13.20
    $ 13.20
    in stock

    For when the old-fashioned hearts just won't cut it! These are similar in size to our classic hearts, so they'll blend right in. Includes 6 designs...

    View full details
    $ 16.50
    $ 16.50 - $ 16.50
    $ 16.50
    $ 13.20
    $ 13.20 - $ 13.20
    $ 13.20
    Save 20% Save %
  • 2 Piece Mini Conversation Hearts Stencil - The Cookie Countess

    2 Piece Mini Conversation Hearts Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 11.00 - $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
    $ 11.00 - $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
    in stock

    Mini Conversation Hearts 2 Piece Stencil for Valentine's Day. Overall size approximately 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open sections...

    View full details
    $ 11.00 - $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
    $ 11.00 - $ 11.00
    $ 11.00
  • Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    This cutter is the ultimate Conversation Heart shape! Designed to fit perfectly with our Conversation Heart 3 Piece Stencil Set. Cutter size is 3.2...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Modern Conversation Hearts Mini 1" Sayings Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    Modern Conversation Hearts Mini 1" Sayings Stencil - The Cookie Countess

    Modern Conversation Hearts Mini 1" Sayings Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    YAS QUEEN! Modern sayings to express your true feelings. These are similar in size to our classic hearts, so they'll blend right in. 9 separate des...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50

  • Conversation Hearts Classic Mini 1" Sayings Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Conversation Hearts Valentine's Day stencil. 9 designs on one stencil. Overall size approximately 5.5" x 5.5". Each phrase is about 1". For easies...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
  • Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large - The Cookie Countess
    Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large - The Cookie Countess

    Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    in stock

    Put a professional finish on your packaged cookies with these bag toppers. The back has a space to write your business information or a nice messag...

    View full details
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
  • Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large - The Cookie Countess
    Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large - The Cookie Countess

    Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    in stock

    Put a professional finish on your packaged cookies with these bag toppers. The back has a space to write your business information or a nice messag...

    View full details
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
    $ 7.50 - $ 7.50
    $ 7.50
  • Bag Topper 3" - Conversation Hearts Mini - The Cookie Countess
    Bag Topper 3" - Conversation Hearts Mini - The Cookie Countess

    Bag Topper 3" - Conversation Hearts Mini

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 6.50 - $ 6.50
    $ 6.50
    $ 6.50 - $ 6.50
    $ 6.50
    in stock

    MINI 3" wide topper is perfect for small cookies or cookie sticks. Put a professional finish on your packaged cookies with these bag toppers. Simpl...

    View full details
    $ 6.50 - $ 6.50
    $ 6.50
    $ 6.50 - $ 6.50
    $ 6.50

  • Scattered Hearts Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    in stock

    Scattered hearts stencil is perfect for weddings, baby showers, Valentine's Day, or just to say "I Love You!" Overall size is approximately 5.5" x...

    View full details
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50