Skip to content
Halloween Cookie Supplies Shop

Halloween Cookie Supplies Shop

  • Halloween PYO Pumpkin Kit

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 66.20
    Original price $ 66.20 - Original price $ 66.20
    Original price $ 66.20
    Current price $ 52.99
    $ 52.99 - $ 52.99
    Current price $ 52.99
    in stock

    Make 10 (or more) PYO Pumpkin Sets with this limited kit! Includes: Both LARGE PYO Pumpkin Stencils Both SMALL PYO Pumpkin Stencils 2 matching pum...

    View full details
    Original price $ 66.20
    Original price $ 66.20 - Original price $ 66.20
    Original price $ 66.20
    Current price $ 52.99
    $ 52.99 - $ 52.99
    Current price $ 52.99
    Save 20% Save %
  • Halloween Candy PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Halloween Candy PYO stencil. Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber.  Use on it's own or as a PYO. Design size 2.75...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Pumpkin with Candy PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    A Jack o Lantern bursting with candy is a fun PYO for Halloween. Design Size is 3 x 2.7 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections i...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Spooky Shack - 4 Piece Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 16.50
    Original price $ 16.50 - Original price $ 16.50
    Original price $ 16.50
    Current price $ 14.00
    $ 14.00 - $ 14.00
    Current price $ 14.00
    in stock

    All the ghouls come to hang at the Spooky Shack! Make a cookie Halloween house your new tradition. After the cookies are made and iced, and the des...

    View full details
    Original price $ 16.50
    Original price $ 16.50 - Original price $ 16.50
    Original price $ 16.50
    Current price $ 14.00
    $ 14.00 - $ 14.00
    Current price $ 14.00
    Save 15% Save %
  • Halloween Bat Cookie Cutter

    Ann Clark
    Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
    Original price
    $ 2.99
    $ 2.99 - $ 2.99
    Current price $ 2.99
    in stock

    Bat Cookie Cutter 4.9 Size: 2.7" x 4.9" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwasher s...

    View full details
    Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
    Original price
    $ 2.99
    $ 2.99 - $ 2.99
    Current price $ 2.99
  • Funny Face Bag Toppers - Set of 5 Halloween

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 12.00 - Original price $ 12.00
    Original price
    $ 12.00
    $ 12.00 - $ 12.00
    Current price $ 12.00
    in stock

    Create a Funny Face Cookie that's sure to delight! Use this bag topper with our Funny Face cookie cutter and decorate it to match. Give you creatio...

    View full details
    Original price $ 12.00 - Original price $ 12.00
    Original price
    $ 12.00
    $ 12.00 - $ 12.00
    Current price $ 12.00
  • PYO Paint Palettes - Halloween

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.99 - Original price $ 5.99
    Original price
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    Current price $ 5.99
    in stock

    Edible paint in 4 colors (colors appear darker then final result) - orange, purple, yellow and green.  Palettes come 12 to a pouch. Leave in pouch...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.99 - Original price $ 5.99
    Original price
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    Current price $ 5.99
  • Witch's Brew Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Designed by the talented Drawn with Character -Witch Brew PYO stencil for Halloween.  Design size is 2.15 x 2.75"   Use as a Paint your Own stencil...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Sugar Skull Bow and Hearts PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    This stencil will fit Ann Clark's Skull Cookie Cutter, sold separately.  Design Size is 1.9 x 2.9 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Sugar Skull with Flower Crown PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    This stencil will fit Ann Clark's Skull Cookie Cutter, sold separately.  Design Size is 1.9 x 2.9 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Large Pumpkin PYO Stencils, Set of 2

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    These two Jack O Lantern PYO stencils were designed to fit a 4" Pumpkin Cookie Cutter, sold separately.  Each design is approximately 2.4 x 2.9 inc...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Small Pumpkin PYO Stencils, Set of 2

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    These two Jack O Lantern PYO stencils were designed to fit a 3" Pumpkin Cookie Cutter, sold separately.  Each design is approximately 1.8 x 2.1 inc...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 8.49
    Original price
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    $ 5.50 - $ 8.49
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Hanging Out Bat PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    A cute vampire bat hanging out waiting for Halloween! Design Size is 2.1 x 2.8" Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Frequent Flyer Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Which is your favorite frequent flyer? Witches, bats, owls, or Harry Potter? Design Size is 2.6 x 2.25 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Sweater Witch PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    This witch is a cozy sweater is ready for Halloween. Design Size is 2.1 x 2.8" Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Pumpkin Witch PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Pumpkin Witch stencil. Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Design size is 3"  Use as a Paint your Own stencil, ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Paint a Pumpkin PYO Tag with Instructions, Pack of 25

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Get 25 professionally printed cards that include PYO pumpkin cookie instructions, for creating Jack o Lantern kits for Halloween. Pack of 25 Eac...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • Haunted House PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
    in stock

    Haunted House PYO stencil. Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Use on it's own or as a PYO.  Overall stencil si...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
    Original price
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    Current price $ 5.50
  • PYO Paint Brushes

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 6.25 - Original price $ 6.25
    Original price
    $ 6.25
    $ 6.25 - $ 6.25
    Current price $ 6.25
    in stock

    Disposable paint brushes to accompany your PYO cookies. These are high quality brushes with soft bristles for easier painting! Sold in packs of 5 ...

    View full details
    Original price $ 6.25 - Original price $ 6.25
    Original price
    $ 6.25
    $ 6.25 - $ 6.25
    Current price $ 6.25
  • Bag Topper 5" with PYO Instructions - Halloween

    The Cookie Countess
    Original price $ 7.50
    Original price $ 7.50 - Original price $ 7.50
    Original price $ 7.50
    Current price $ 6.38
    $ 6.38 - $ 6.38
    Current price $ 6.38
    in stock

    Put a professional finish on your cookies with these cute bag toppers. The inside has simple instructions on how to paint a PYO cookie using, and t...

    View full details
    Original price $ 7.50
    Original price $ 7.50 - Original price $ 7.50
    Original price $ 7.50
    Current price $ 6.38
    $ 6.38 - $ 6.38
    Current price $ 6.38
    Save 15% Save %
  • Parchment Texture Sheets - Halloween Spiderwebs

    Intricut Edibles
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
    in stock

    These 4 inch by 4 inch sheets of parchment paper have a 3D embossed design on them and can be used to give your icing depth and dimension. Pack of...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
  • Parchment Texture Sheets - Halloween Icons

    Intricut Edibles
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
    in stock

    These 4 inch by 4 inch sheets of parchment paper have a 3D embossed design on them and can be used to give your icing depth and dimension. Pack of...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
  • Parchment Texture Sheets - Halloween Icons 2

    Intricut Edibles
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
    in stock

    These 4 inch by 4 inch sheets of parchment paper have a 3D embossed design on them and can be used to give your icing depth and dimension. Pack of...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
  • Parchment Texture Sheets - Halloween Bats

    Intricut Edibles
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75
    in stock

    These 4 inch by 4 inch sheets of parchment paper have a 3D embossed design on them and can be used to give your icing depth and dimension. Pack of...

    View full details
    Original price $ 5.75 - Original price $ 5.75
    Original price
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    Current price $ 5.75