Skip to content
$5.99 Shipping or ⭐️ Free Shipping on orders over $75 in the Cont. US
⭐️ Free Shipping on orders over $75 in the Cont. US
Order Support Countess Rewards My Wishlist ❤ Recipes Shipping & Returns

Valentine’s Day PYO Shop!

"Paint Your Own" cookies are the perfect sweet treat for Valentine's day! More information on making PYO cookies can be found here. As well as the perfect way to pack them here! 

Fairy Bear PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess Save 83% Save %
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99

Fairy Bear PYO Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Your wish is granted! The Fairy Princess Teddy Bear is here with her wings and flower crown. Design Size is 2.5 x 2.65 inches Overall stencil size ...

View full details
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99
Save 83% Save %
Cat Balloon 3" PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
Cat Balloon 3" PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess Save 83% Save %
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99

Cat Balloon 3" PYO Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

This kitty is floating over to say he loves you (and that his food bowl is empty). Design size is approximately 1.5 x 3" Overall stencil size is 5....

View full details
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99
Save 83% Save %
Let's AvoCuddle Stencil - The Cookie Countess
Let's AvoCuddle Stencil - The Cookie Countess Save 83% Save %
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99

Let's AvoCuddle Stencil

The Cookie Countess
Only 4 left!

Let's AvoCuddle stencil has two cute avocados, ready for Valentine's Day. Design size is approximately 2.55" x 3.5" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". P...

View full details
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
$ 0.99
$ 0.99 - $ 0.99
$ 0.99
Save 83% Save %
Big Cat Love PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
$ 5.50
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99

Big Cat Love PYO Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Lions and Tigers and Hearts - oh my! Kids will love painting these cute animals. Design Size is 3 x 2.15 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5"...

View full details
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
$ 5.50
$ 5.99
$ 5.99 - $ 5.99
$ 5.99
Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Heart Flutter - The Cookie Countess
Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Heart Flutter - The Cookie Countess
Sold out
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50

Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Heart Flutter

The Cookie Countess
Out of Stock

Put a professional finish on your cookies with these cute bag toppers. The inside has simple instructions on how to paint a PYO cookie using, and t...

View full details
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
Sold out
Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large - The Cookie Countess
Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large - The Cookie Countess
Sold out
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99

Bag Topper 5" - You're A Sweetheart Large

The Cookie Countess
Out of Stock

Put a professional finish on your packaged cookies with these bag toppers. The back has a space to write your business information or a nice messag...

View full details
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
Sold out
Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large - The Cookie Countess
Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large - The Cookie Countess
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99

Bag Topper 5" - Conversation Hearts Large

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Put a professional finish on your packaged cookies with these bag toppers. The back has a space to write your business information or a nice messag...

View full details
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
$ 8.99 - $ 8.99
$ 8.99
Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Rainbow Brush - The Cookie Countess
Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Rainbow Brush - The Cookie Countess
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50

Bag Topper 4" with PYO Instructions - Rainbow Brush

The Cookie Countess
Only 5 left!

Put a professional finish on your cookies with these cute rainbow splatter art bag toppers. The inside has simple instructions on how to paint a PY...

View full details
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
$ 8.50 - $ 8.50
$ 8.50
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 1/2 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 1/2 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.75
$ 7.75 - $ 7.75
$ 7.75

Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 1/2 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100

The Cookie Countess
in stock

100 Clear lip & tape Bags 3 1/2" x 5 1/2". Non gusseted (flat) bags. These crystal clear, self sealing bags, are great for packaging individual...

View full details
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.75
$ 7.75 - $ 7.75
$ 7.75
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 3/4 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 3/4 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.49
$ 7.49 - $ 7.49
$ 7.49

Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 3/4 x 5 1/2" - pack of 100

The Cookie Countess
in stock

  100 Clear lip & tape Bags 3 3/4" x 5 1/2". Non gusseted (flat) bags. These crystal clear, self sealing bags, are great for packaging individu...

View full details
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.49
$ 7.49 - $ 7.49
$ 7.49
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 7/8 x 5 1/4" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 7/8 x 5 1/4" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.99
$ 7.99 - $ 7.99
$ 7.99

Clear Lip & Tape Bags 3 7/8 x 5 1/4" - pack of 100

The Cookie Countess
in stock

100 Clear lip & tape Bags 3 7/8" x 5 1/4". Non gusseted (flat) bags. ContentThese are the perfect size to fit one of our Paint Palettes and sho...

View full details
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.99
$ 7.99 - $ 7.99
$ 7.99
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 4 1/4 x 5 1/8" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
Clear Lip & Tape Bags 4 1/4 x 5 1/8" - pack of 100 - The Cookie Countess
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.99
$ 7.99 - $ 7.99
$ 7.99

Clear Lip & Tape Bags 4 1/4 x 5 1/8" - pack of 100

The Cookie Countess
in stock

  100 Clear lip & tape Bags 4 1/4" x 5 1/8". Non gusseted (flat) bags. These crystal clear, self sealing bags, are great for packaging individu...

View full details
$ 0.00 - $ 0.00
$ 0.00
$ 7.99
$ 7.99 - $ 7.99
$ 7.99
Heart Cookie Cutter 3 3/8" - The Cookie Countess
Heart Cookie Cutter 3 3/8" - The Cookie Countess
Save 62% Save %
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50

Heart Cookie Cutter 3 3/8"

Ann Clark
Only 10 left!

Heart Cookie Cutter 3 3/8" Size: 3 3/8" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not d...

View full details
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50
Save 62% Save %
Heart Cookie Cutter 3 5/8" - The Cookie Countess
Heart Cookie Cutter 3 5/8" - The Cookie Countess
Save 62% Save %
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50

Heart Cookie Cutter 3 5/8"

Ann Clark
in stock

Heart Cookie Cutter Size: 3 5/8" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwasher sa...

View full details
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50
Save 62% Save %
Large Heart Cookie Cutter 4" - The Cookie Countess
Large Heart Cookie Cutter 4" - The Cookie Countess
Save 62% Save %
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50

Large Heart Cookie Cutter 4"

Ann Clark
Only 1 left!

Large Heart Cookie Cutter  Size: 4" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwasher...

View full details
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50
Save 62% Save %
Heart Cookie Cutter 4" - The Cookie Countess
Heart Cookie Cutter 4" - The Cookie Countess
Save 62% Save %
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50

Heart Cookie Cutter 4"

Ann Clark
in stock

Heart Cookie Cutter Size: 4" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwasher safe. ...

View full details
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50
Save 62% Save %
Extra Large Heart Cookie Cutter 5" - The Cookie Countess
Extra Large Heart Cookie Cutter 5" - The Cookie Countess
Save 62% Save %
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50

Extra Large Heart Cookie Cutter 5"

Ann Clark
in stock

Extra Large Heart Cookie Cutter  Size: 5" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dish...

View full details
$ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
$ 3.99
$ 1.50
$ 1.50 - $ 1.50
$ 1.50
Save 62% Save %
Single Cookie Presentation Box - The Cookie Countess
Single Cookie Presentation Box - The Cookie Countess
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00

Single Cookie Presentation Box

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Exclusively at The Cookie Countess! We designed this box for you to showcase a single cookie (or a set of minis). This packaging is great for PYOs,...

View full details
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00 - $ 79.99
$ 5.00
Chunky Boo! Plaque Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
Cookie Box 8.5 x 4.75 x 1.5 'Good Things' - The Cookie Countess
Save 13% Save %
$ 74.97
$ 74.97 - $ 74.97
$ 74.97
$ 64.99
$ 64.99 - $ 64.99
$ 64.99

Cookie Box 8.5 x 4.75 x 1.5 'Good Things (BUY ONE SET, GET ONE SET FREE!)

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Weekend BOGO BUY ONE SET, GET ONE SET FREE! Must add two to cart for discount.    Exclusively at The Cookie Countess! We designed this box for you ...

View full details
$ 74.97
$ 74.97 - $ 74.97
$ 74.97
$ 64.99
$ 64.99 - $ 64.99
$ 64.99
Save 13% Save %