Skip to content
⭐️Annual Stencil Sale ends June 7th - Shop Now!⭐️
⭐️Annual Stencil Sale ends June 7th - Shop Now!⭐️
Countess Rewards My Wishlist ❤ Recipes Shipping & Returns

Valentine’s Day PYO Shop!

"Paint Your Own" cookies are the perfect sweet treat for Valentine's day! More information on making PYO cookies can be found here. As well as the perfect way to pack them here! 

  • PYO Paint Palettes - Valentine's Day - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Supplies PYO Paint Palettes - Valentine's Day

    PYO Paint Palettes - Valentine's Day

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    in stock

    Edible Paint Palettes in sweet Valentine's Day colors. Edible paint in 4 colors: Red, Purple, Neon Pink, Muted Pink. Palettes come 12 to a pouch. ...

    View full details
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
    $ 5.99 - $ 5.99
    $ 5.99
  • The Cookie Countess PYO Supplies Paint Palettes- Sweet Six
    The Cookie Countess PYO Supplies Paint Palettes- Sweet Six

    Paint Palettes- Sweet Six

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 3.49 - $ 3.49
    $ 3.49
    $ 3.49 - $ 3.49
    $ 3.49
    in stock

    Palettes of edible paint, that works just like watercolors. You can use these palettes with our PYO (Paint Your Own) cookie designs, or simply as ...

    View full details
    $ 3.49 - $ 3.49
    $ 3.49
    $ 3.49 - $ 3.49
    $ 3.49
  • PYO Paint Palettes - Brights - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Supplies PYO Paint Palettes - Brights

    PYO Paint Palettes - Brights

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 6.49 - $ 6.49
    $ 6.49
    $ 6.49 - $ 6.49
    $ 6.49
    in stock

    Palettes of edible paint, that works just like watercolors. You can use these palettes with our PYO (Paint Your Own) cookie designs, or simply as ...

    View full details
    $ 6.49 - $ 6.49
    $ 6.49
    $ 6.49 - $ 6.49
    $ 6.49
  • PYO Paint Brushes - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Supplies 5 dozen Food Safe Paint Brushes for PYO Cookies - Pack of 60

    Food Safe Paint Brushes for PYO Cookies - Pack of 60

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    in stock

    Disposable paint brushes to accompany your PYO cookies. These are high quality brushes with soft bristles for easier painting! Sold in packs of 5 ...

    View full details
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
    $ 6.75 - $ 6.75
    $ 6.75
  • The Cookie Countess Packaging Valentine's Day Cookie Bag
    The Cookie Countess Packaging Valentine's Day Cookie Bag
    Save up to 20% Save %

    Valentine's Day Cookie Bag

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 10.99 - $ 49.99
    $ 10.99 - $ 49.99
    $ 10.99
    $ 9.99 - $ 39.99
    $ 9.99 - $ 39.99
    $ 9.99
    in stock

    Give your Valentines a sweet treat in these adorable bags! This cute pouch can elevate your Valentine's cookies to the next level, and the bow does...

    View full details
    $ 10.99 - $ 49.99
    $ 10.99 - $ 49.99
    $ 10.99
    $ 9.99 - $ 39.99
    $ 9.99 - $ 39.99
    $ 9.99
    Save up to 20% Save %
  • LOVE word PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil LOVE word PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    Save 20% Save %

    LOVE word PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. LOVE word stencil. Design size is 3.75" x 1.5"  Use as a Paint your Own ste...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Unicorn with Heart PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Unicorn with Heart PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Unicorn with Heart PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Unicorn with Heart stencil.  Design size is 2.75 x 2.69"  Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as it's own design! Overall stencil size is approxima...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • The Cookie Countess Cookie Cutter Unicorn with Heart Cutter
    Unicorn with Heart Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Unicorn with Heart Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 4.75 - $ 4.75
    $ 4.75
    $ 4.75 - $ 4.75
    $ 4.75
    in stock

    Unicorn with Heart - Cutter only  Find the stencil here All elements of this original cookie cutter were designed by The Cookie Countess w...

    View full details
    $ 4.75 - $ 4.75
    $ 4.75
    $ 4.75 - $ 4.75
    $ 4.75
  • Love Bug PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Love Bug PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    Save 20% Save %

    Love Bug PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Love Bug stencil. Design size is 2.75" x 3.75"  Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as it's own design! Overall stencil size is approximately 5.5" ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Love Bug - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Love Bug - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Love Bug - Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    Love Bug Cookie Cutter - stencil sold separately.    This cutter is designed specifically to work with our Love Bug stencil. They're the per...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Conversation Hearts PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Conversation Hearts PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    Save 20% Save %

    Conversation Hearts PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Conversation Hearts stencil. Matching cookie cutter can be found here. Desi...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    This cutter has been designed to pair perfectly with our Drawn by Krista - Conversation Hearts PYO stencil. Cutter size is 3.5" x 3" All elements o...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Dino-Mite PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Dino-Mite PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Dino-Mite PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Dino-Mite stencil. Design size is approximately 1.36" x 2.75" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open sections. Stencils ...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Puppy Love PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Puppy Love PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Puppy Love PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Puppy Love stencil. Design size is approximately 2.12" x 2.65" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open sections. Stencils...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess
    Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter - The Cookie Countess

    Large Conversation Heart - Cookie Cutter

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    This cutter is the ultimate Conversation Heart shape! Designed to fit perfectly with our Conversation Heart 3 Piece Stencil Set. Cutter size is 3.2...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Llama PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Default Llama PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Llama PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Llama Paint Your Own stencil.  Design size is 1.97" x 3" Overall stencil size approximately 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open sectio...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Donut Love PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Donut Love PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Donut Love PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Donut Love Stencil. Design Size 3.25" x 2.6" Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as it's own design! Overall stencil size is approximately 5.5" x 5...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Sweetie Unicorn PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Sweetie Unicorn PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Sweetie Unicorn PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Sweetie Unicorn PYO stencil. Design size is 2.75" x 2.65"   Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as its own design! Overall stencil size is approxi...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • You're Turtley Awesome Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil You're Turtley Awesome Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    You're Turtley Awesome Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    You're Turtley Awesome stencil. Design size is approximately 2.65"x 2.32" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open section...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Default Cupid Unicorn PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Default Cupid Unicorn PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    Save 20% Save %

    Cupid Unicorn PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Cupid Unicorn stencil. Design size is 3" x 2.77"  Use as a Paint your Own s...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Penguin and Heart PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Default Penguin and Heart PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista
    Save 20% Save %

    Penguin and Heart PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Penguin and heart stencil. Design size is 2.25" x 3.75" Use as a Paint your Own stencil, or as it's own design! Overall stencil size is approximate...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %
  • Penguin with Heart Cookie Cutter ONLY - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess Cookie Cutter Penguin with Heart Cookie Cutter ONLY

    Penguin with Heart Cookie Cutter ONLY

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    in stock

    Penguin with Heart Cookie Cutter - stencil sold separately.    This cutter is designed specifically to work with our Penguin with Heart sten...

    View full details
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
    $ 5.75 - $ 5.75
    $ 5.75
  • Pizza PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Pizza PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Pizza PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 4.50
    $ 4.50 - $ 4.50
    $ 4.50
    $ 3.60
    $ 3.60 - $ 3.60
    $ 3.60
    in stock

    Pizza PYO stencil.  Design size is approximately 2.5 x 2.6" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in image are the open sections. Stencils ar...

    View full details
    $ 4.50
    $ 4.50 - $ 4.50
    $ 4.50
    $ 3.60
    $ 3.60 - $ 3.60
    $ 3.60
    Save 20% Save %
  • Berries PYO Stencil - The Cookie Countess
    The Cookie Countess PYO Stencil Default Berries PYO Stencil
    Save 20% Save %

    Berries PYO Stencil

    The Cookie Countess
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    in stock

    Berries PYO stencil featuring strawberry, blueberry, and cherry. Design size is approximately 2 x 2.15" Overall size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections...

    View full details
    $ 5.50
    $ 5.50 - $ 5.50
    $ 5.50
    $ 4.40
    $ 4.40 - $ 4.40
    $ 4.40
    Save 20% Save %