Skip to content
Free US Contiguous Standard Shipping on orders $35+ 📦
Free US Contiguous Standard Shipping on orders $35+ 📦
Christmas Baking Supplies

Christmas Baking Supplies

Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

Christmas Finial Ornament Cookie Cutter 4 1/4"

Ann Clark
in stock

Christmas Finial Ornament Cutter  Size: 4 1/4" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not d...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

MINI Mitten Cookie Cutter 2 1/8"

Ann Clark
in stock

Mini Mitten Cookie Cutter Size 2 1/8" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwasher...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

MINI Reindeer Cookie Cutter 2 1/4"

Ann Clark
in stock

Mini Reindeer Cookie Cutter Size:  2 1/4" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwa...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 1.99 - Original price $ 1.99
Original price
$ 1.99
$ 1.99 - $ 1.99
Current price $ 1.99

Mini Truck with Tree 2.5" Cookie Cutter

American Tradition
in stock

Adorable 2.5" Mini Truck with Christmas Tree cookie cutter. This cookie cutter is proudly made by American Traditions cookie cutter company in Pe...

View full details
Original price $ 1.99 - Original price $ 1.99
Original price
$ 1.99
$ 1.99 - $ 1.99
Current price $ 1.99
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

Leaping Reindeer Cookie Cutter 3 1/2"

Ann Clark
in stock

Leaping Reindeer Cutter  Size:  3 1/2" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwashe...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 14.00 - Original price $ 14.00
Original price
$ 14.00
$ 14.00 - $ 14.00
Current price $ 14.00

Cookie Scribe - Winter Wonderland

Sweeties Tasty Treats
Only 3 left!

A handmade, elegant scribe from Sweeties Tasty Treats! This scribe has Crystal & Frost Blue plastic beads, and a silver snowflake charm on the ...

View full details
Original price $ 14.00 - Original price $ 14.00
Original price
$ 14.00
$ 14.00 - $ 14.00
Current price $ 14.00
Original price $ 14.00 - Original price $ 14.00
Original price
$ 14.00
$ 14.00 - $ 14.00
Current price $ 14.00

Cookie Scribe - Snow Disco

Sweeties Tasty Treats
Only 4 left!

A handmade, elegant scribe from Sweeties Tasty Treats! This scribe has silver & white plastic beads, and a silver whisk charm on the top. Scrib...

View full details
Original price $ 14.00 - Original price $ 14.00
Original price
$ 14.00
$ 14.00 - $ 14.00
Current price $ 14.00
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

Flour Box Snowman Head Cookie Cutter 3 7/8"

Ann Clark
in stock

Flour Box Bakery Snowman Head Size: 3 7/8" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishwashe...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99

Snowman with Scarf 3.5" Cookie Cutter

Ann Clark
in stock

Snowman with Scarf Cookie Cutter Size: 3 1/2" Made in the USA Certified Safe for Lead and Cadmium. US made tin-plated Steel. Hand wash, not dishw...

View full details
Original price $ 2.99 - Original price $ 2.99
Original price
$ 2.99
$ 2.99 - $ 2.99
Current price $ 2.99
Original price $ 12.00 - Original price $ 12.00
Original price
$ 12.00
$ 12.00 - $ 12.00
Current price $ 12.00

Funny Face Bag Topper WINTER, 50 Cards

The Cookie Countess
Only 8 left!

Create a Funny Face Cookie that's sure to delight! Use this bag topper with our Funny Face cookie cutter and decorate it to match. Give your creati...

View full details
Original price $ 12.00 - Original price $ 12.00
Original price
$ 12.00
$ 12.00 - $ 12.00
Current price $ 12.00
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
Current price $ 3.99

Funny Face Bag Topper 6" - Santa

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Create a Funny Face Cookie that's sure to delight! Use this bag topper with our Funny Face cookie cutter and decorate it to match. Give your creati...

View full details
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
Current price $ 3.99
Save 50% Save %
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.49
$ 3.49 - $ 3.49
Current price $ 3.49

Funny Face Bag Topper 6" - Elf

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Create a Funny Face Cookie that's sure to delight! Use this bag topper with our Funny Face cookie cutter and decorate it to match. Give your creati...

View full details
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.49
$ 3.49 - $ 3.49
Current price $ 3.49
Save 56% Save %
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
Current price $ 3.99

Funny Face Bag Topper 6" - Yeti

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Create a Funny Face Cookie that's sure to delight! Use this bag topper with our Funny Face cookie cutter and decorate it to match. Give your creati...

View full details
Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00 - Original price $ 8.00
Original price $ 8.00
Current price $ 3.99
$ 3.99 - $ 3.99
Current price $ 3.99
Save 50% Save %
Original price $ 16.50 - Original price $ 16.50
Original price
$ 16.50
$ 16.50 - $ 16.50
Current price $ 16.50

Gingerbread House - 4 Piece Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Decorated gingerbread houses are a timeless tradition enjoyed by all ages. At The Cookie Countess we have long offered “Paint Your Own” gingerbread...

View full details
Original price $ 16.50 - Original price $ 16.50
Original price
$ 16.50
$ 16.50 - $ 16.50
Current price $ 16.50
Original price $ 34.99
Original price $ 34.99 - Original price $ 34.99
Original price $ 34.99
Current price $ 24.99
$ 24.99 - $ 24.99
Current price $ 24.99

The Cookie Countess 'Paint Your Own' Gingerbread House Kit

The Cookie Countess
Only 7 left!

Decorated gingerbread houses are a timeless tradition enjoyed by all ages. At The Cookie Countess we have long offered “Paint Your Own” gingerbread...

View full details
Original price $ 34.99
Original price $ 34.99 - Original price $ 34.99
Original price $ 34.99
Current price $ 24.99
$ 24.99 - $ 24.99
Current price $ 24.99
Save 29% Save %
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Gingerbread House PYO Stencil - Drawn by Krista

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Gingerbread House PYO stencil. Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Design size is 3 x 2.87"  Use as a Paint you...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 9.99
Original price
$ 5.50 - $ 9.99
$ 5.50 - $ 9.99
Current price $ 5.50

Snow Globe Scene PYO

The Cookie Countess
in stock

 Snow Globe Scene PYO - Buy the stencil, cutter, or both and save!    Snow Globe Scene PYO Stencil - Design size is 2.7" x 3.25" Use as a Paint you...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 9.99
Original price
$ 5.50 - $ 9.99
$ 5.50 - $ 9.99
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 39.48
Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 39.48
Original price $ 27.50
$ 24.75 - $ 29.95
$ 24.75 - $ 29.95
Current price $ 24.75

Christmas Train PYO Cookie Stencil Set

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Use all five stencils to create a unique train collection! Original art for The Cookie Countess by illustrator Krista Heij-Barber. Includes Santa E...

View full details
Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 39.48
Original price $ 27.50 - Original price $ 39.48
Original price $ 27.50
$ 24.75 - $ 29.95
$ 24.75 - $ 29.95
Current price $ 24.75
Save up to 24% Save %
Original price $ 20.99 - Original price $ 20.99
Original price
$ 20.99
$ 20.99 - $ 20.99
Current price $ 20.99

Paint Palettes 36 Pouch - Christmas

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Enjoy a bulk pack of 36 PYO palettes in a cute pouch! While our palettes normally come in simple white packaging, you might want a more attractive...

View full details
Original price $ 20.99 - Original price $ 20.99
Original price
$ 20.99
$ 20.99 - $ 20.99
Current price $ 20.99
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Fair Isle Sweater Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Fair Isle Sweater stencil. A best seller!  Makes the classic sweater pattern.  Overall stencil size approximately 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in im...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Cookie Stick Stencil - Holly Jolly / Jingle Bells

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Celebrate Christmas and winter with these fun sayings. Each saying is 2.9 x .85" Overall size is approximately 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections in im...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Winter Friends PYO Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

This sweet bear and penguin chick are all cozied up for Christmas. Design Size is 3 x 2.5 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". PINK sections...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Cuddling Penguins PYO Stencil

The Cookie Countess
in stock

These two penguin chicks are wrapped in a winter scarf, staying warm and cozy. Design Size is 3 x 2.2 inches Overall stencil size is 5.5" x 5.5". P...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50

Cookie Stick Stencil - Hot Cocoa Bar Sign

The Cookie Countess
in stock

Use both parts of this stencil to make a rustic farmhouse sign perfect for Christmas or winter. We recommend using airbrush for the snowflakes, let...

View full details
Original price $ 5.50 - Original price $ 5.50
Original price
$ 5.50
$ 5.50 - $ 5.50
Current price $ 5.50