Skip to content
⏰ BLACK FRIDAY SPECIAL: Free US Contiguous Standard Shipping on orders $20+ 📦
⏰ BLACK FRIDAY SPECIAL: Free US Contiguous Standard Shipping on orders $20+ 📦

Buttery Goodness Flavoring

Original price $ 7.49 - Original price $ 11.99
Original price
$ 7.49
$ 7.49 - $ 11.99
Current price $ 7.49
Size: 4 oz
Free Shipping Icon

Free shipping $35+

30-Day Returns Icon

30-Day Returns

Limited Time offer! Buy one Get one FREE 4oz bottle! Must add 2 to your cart to activate discount.

How do you get that bakery taste at home? We have the answer!

For years, The Cookie Countess owner Hillary's secret to achieving rich, buttery cookies has been a high quality imitation butter flavoring. Use this blend in your cookie recipe (you can mix it with vanilla, lemon, or your signature flavor), or in your royal icing.

Of course, it's not limited to just cookies. Try it in your cakes, muffins, buttercream, or anywhere else you need some Buttery Goodness!

  • Kosher
  • Made in the USA
  • Ingredients: Soybean Oil, Corn Oil, Artificial Flavor. Made on equipment that also processes wheat, milk, eggs, soy, and tree nuts.
  • Now available in two sizes, 4oz and 8 oz

THIS PRODUCT CAN NOT BE SHIPPED INTERNATIONALLY. 

 

Best by May 2025

Availability:
in stock, ready to be shipped
Availability:
in stock, ready to be shipped

Leave reviews, get rewarded!

Got your goodies? We're all ears and can't wait to hear your thoughts! Once you've had the chance to enjoy your products, please share your experience with us. For every unique product review, you'll earn 50 Countess Rewards points—just make sure to use the email associated with your Countess Rewards account. To keep our reviews genuine and helpful, we kindly ask for one review per product, per purchase. No repeats necessary—save those for the new products you discover!

Want a chance to win a $50 gift card? Upload a picture with your review! Once a month we will choose a picture review at random for this sweet prize!

Need more info or a little help? Learn more about Countess Rewards by clicking here.

Customer Reviews

Based on 31 reviews
97%
(30)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
3%
(1)
M
Mona Ridgway (Fort Worth, US)
Yummmmm!

Hands down the best buttery flavoring! Takes my sugar cookies over the top. Gives them that perfect buttery bite!

L
Lorraine Macholz (Patchogue, US)
Best Flavor

I am beyond excited this is finally back. What an amazing flavor it has. Love using it all the time in my cookies. Yummy!!!

J
Judith
Just buy it!

This stuff right here kicks up the flavor of your cookies. So, so delicious 🤤 you won’t be disappointed

M
Myriam
Great flavor

I mix this with clear vanilla to for a subtle butter flavor. It’s not overpowering and goes well with other extracts.

T
Tina Marie Loreto
buttery

deliciousness in a bottle...